Conclusion



Having read the evidence presented directly by Friedman, Brogan, and Ellison, and indirectly by host of others, and despite any disclaimers Tolkien wrote to the contrary, Tolkien's work seems to have legitimate roots within both World Wars. That is not to say that Tolkien's work should again be interpreted as a form of allegory -- neither Tolkien nor I should wish for nor appreciate that. Nor even that one should go digging for what Tolkien would much rather you didn't find -- neither of us would appreciate that either. It is merely to say that the two wars did have some influence on how the story came to be told.

On the other hand, there are different types of influence. Grant C. Sterling explains:

...There can be no doubt, for example, that WW I experiences influenced Tolkien's descriptions of certain things, such as the Morannon. The passages you give demonstrate such things effectively [and Tolkien admitted as much]. It is another thing for something to affect the theme of a work of literature, or the main thrust of the plot. What Tolkien was denying was that either war had much effect on _those_ sorts of fundamental things. {And that is what I, myself, was trying to deny as well.} This is not to take away from the value of pointing out instances of the first sort of influence...(51)

Having concluded this, we can now go back to sleep, reenter Middle-earth, and continue to engage in such escapism as The Lord of the Rings readily invites us into and was most assuredly written for. (Or was it? But that, my friends, is a whole nother can of worms, which I shall leave for someone to pry open and delve into.)



briankessler@nowhereatall.net | 10 December 1998





This page was prepared by Brian Matthew Kessler of Nowhere@All
The Subversive Expressionist Brian Matthew Kessler's HomePage: NoWhere @ AllBrian Matthew Kessler's Surrealism HomePage: NoWhere @ AllThe Misanthropic Messiah Brian Matthew Kessler's HomePage: NoWhere @ AllBrian Matthew Kessler's Art HomePage: NoWhere @ AllThe Artist Brian Matthew Kessler's HomePage: NoWhere @ AllThe Expressionist Brian Matthew Kessler's HomePage: NoWhere @ AllBrian Matthew Kessler's Life HomePage: NoWhere @ AllThe Madman Brian Matthew Kessler's HomePage: NoWhere @ AllBrian Matthew Kessler's Subversive HomePage: NoWhere @ AllBholanath of the Dreaming's HomePage: NoWhere @ AllBholanath of the Dreaming's HomePage: NoWhere @ AllBholanath of the Crimson Tongues's HomePage: NoWhere @ AllBholanath of the Dreaming's HomePage: NoWhere @ AllBrian/Bryan Matthew Kessler's HomePage: NoWhere @ AllBrian Matthew Kessler/Kestler's HomePage: NoWhere @ AllBrian Matthew Kessler's Liberty HomePage: NoWhere @ AllBrian Matthew Kessler's Love HomePage: NoWhere @ AllBrian Matthew Kessler's HomePage: NoWhere @ AllThw Messiah Brian Matthew Kessler's HomePage: NoWhere @ AllThe Misanthrope Brian Matthew Kessler's HomePage: NoWhere @ AllThe Surrealist Brian Matthew Kessler's HomePage: NoWhere @ AllBrian Matthew Kessler's HomePage: NoWhere @ AllBrian Matthew Kessler's HomePage: NoWhere @ AllBrian Matthew Kessler's HomePage: NoWhere @ AllBrian Matthew Kessler's HomePage: NoWhere @ AllBrian Matthew Kessler's HomePage: NoWhere @ AllBrian Matthew Kessler's enLightenment HomePage: NoWhere @ AllBrian Matthew Kessler's HomePage: NoWhere @ AllBrian Mathew/Matthew Kessler's HomePage: NoWhere @ AllNoWhere @ All: Brian Matthew Kessler's HomePageNoWhere @ All: Brian Matthew Kessler's HomePageIndex: About Brian Matthew KesslerBlank IndexBlank IndexWisdom by Brian Matthew KesslerCreations by Brian Matthew KesslerCreations by Brian Matthew KesslerCreations by Brian Matthew KesslerWisdom by Brian Matthew KesslerWisdom by Brian Matthew KesslerNoWhere @ All: Brian Matthew Kessler's WisdomWisdom by Brian Matthew KesslerWisdom by Brian Matthew KesslerCreations by Brian Matthew KesslerNoWhere @ All: Brian Matthew Kessler's HomePageIndex of Old Letters and JournalsIndex of Old Letters and JournalsIndex of Old Letters and JournalsIndex of Old Letters and JournalsIndex of Old Letters and JournalsIndex of Old Letters and JournalsWisdom by Brian Matthew KesslerNoWhere @ All: Brian Matthew Kessler's WisdomBlank IndexIndex to Other People's CubesWisdom by Brian Matthew KesslerCreations by Brian Matthew KesslerWisdom by Brian Matthew KesslerWisdom by Brian Matthew KesslerWisdom by Brian Matthew KesslerWisdom by Brian Matthew KesslerWisdom by Brian Matthew KesslerWisdom by Brian Matthew KesslerWisdom by Brian Matthew KesslerWisdom by Brian Matthew KesslerThe Tolkien MenuNoWhere @ All: Brian Matthew Kessler's HomePageNoWhere @ All: Brian Matthew Kessler's HomePage